The Art of Biltong: Distinguishing the Good from the Bad

August 7, 2023

Sliced biltong with traditional South African spices

Biltong is one of South Africa’s most iconic dried meat snacks, loved for its rich flavour, high protein content and unique texture. But not all biltong is made the same. The difference between good and bad biltong comes down to the quality of the meat, the spice balance, the curing process and the final texture.

If you are buying biltong in Perth or ordering biltong online, it helps to know what to look for. Good biltong should taste clean, savoury and well-seasoned. Bad biltong can be overly dry, too fatty, poorly spiced or unpleasant in smell and texture.

At Dry Age Biltong in Woodvale, Perth, we make biltong using traditional South African-inspired recipes and methods refined since 1991. Here is how to tell the difference between quality biltong and biltong that should be avoided.

What Is Biltong?

Biltong is dried, cured meat with roots in Southern African food culture. It is usually made from beef, although game meats can also be used. The meat is cut into strips or slabs, seasoned with ingredients such as vinegar, salt, coriander and pepper, then slowly dried.

Unlike jerky, biltong is not usually cooked with heat. It is cured and air-dried, which gives it a different texture and flavour. Biltong can be soft and moist, medium-dry, or very dry depending on personal preference and the way it is prepared.

Characteristics of Good Biltong

Quality beef biltong made from selected cuts of meat

Good biltong starts with good meat. The cut should have the right balance of lean meat and fat, depending on the customer’s preference. Some people prefer lean biltong, while others like biltong with a little fat for extra flavour.

The curing process is also important. Quality biltong should be properly seasoned and dried at the right pace. If it is rushed, the texture and flavour can suffer. If it is dried too long, it can become hard, brittle and difficult to chew.

Good biltong usually has these qualities:

  • Clean meaty smell: It should smell savoury and fresh, with the aroma of meat and spices.
  • Balanced seasoning: The spices should enhance the meat, not overpower it.
  • Good texture: It should match your preference, whether soft, medium or dry, without feeling unpleasant or stale.
  • Quality cut: The meat should not be full of gristle, excessive connective tissue or poor-quality fat.
  • Proper drying: The outside and inside should feel consistent, not wet in the middle or rock-hard throughout unless intentionally dried that way.

Best Meat Cuts for Biltong

The best cuts for biltong are usually lean, firm cuts that dry evenly. Beef topside and silverside are common choices because they have good texture, dry well and slice cleanly.

A good cut gives biltong its signature chew without becoming stringy or unpleasant. The cut matters because biltong is all about texture. Even with the right spices, poor-quality meat can still produce poor-quality biltong.

Worst Meat Cuts for Biltong

While biltong can technically be made from many cuts of meat, some cuts are not ideal. Fatty, gristly or heavily connective cuts can result in biltong that is tough, oily or chewy in the wrong way.

Very thin cuts can also dry too quickly, leaving the biltong brittle and lacking the satisfying texture people expect. The best biltong has balance: good meat, the right thickness, proper seasoning and controlled drying.

Cuts that are usually less suitable for biltong include:

  • Brisket: Brisket has strong flavour, but it can be too fatty and tough for consistent biltong.
  • Shank: Shank has a lot of connective tissue, which can make the final product chewy and unpleasant.
  • Plate or short rib: These cuts can be too fatty, and too much fat can affect flavour and shelf life.
  • Chuck: Chuck can contain more connective tissue and may not dry as cleanly as leaner cuts.

Characteristics of Bad Biltong

Comparison of fatty biltong and lean biltong texture

Bad biltong is often the result of poor meat selection, rushed drying, incorrect storage or seasoning that hides the flavour of the meat instead of improving it.

Warning signs of poor-quality biltong include:

  • Off smell: Biltong should not smell sour, rancid or unpleasant.
  • Bad texture: It should not be slimy, overly wet, stale, brittle or full of gristle.
  • Too much fat: Some fat is fine if you enjoy fatty biltong, but excessive or poor-quality fat can affect taste.
  • Overpowering spice: Heavy spice can be used to mask lower-quality meat.
  • Uneven drying: If the outside is dry but the inside feels unpleasantly wet, the drying process may not have been right.

If biltong smells wrong, looks spoiled or tastes off, do not eat it. Quality biltong should be enjoyable from the first smell through to the final bite.

Common Mistakes in Spicing Biltong

Spicing is one of the most important parts of making biltong. Traditional biltong usually includes coriander, black pepper, salt and vinegar. Some recipes may include chilli, garlic or a small amount of sweetness, depending on the flavour style.

The biggest mistake is over-spicing. Too much spice can hide the natural flavour of the meat. Biltong should taste like quality cured meat first, with spices supporting the flavour in the background.

Under-spicing is the opposite problem. If there is not enough seasoning, the biltong can taste flat or bland. The goal is balance: enough spice to add depth, but not so much that the meat disappears.

How to Choose Good Biltong

Choosing good biltong by checking texture, smell and quality

When choosing biltong, start with the basics: smell, texture, colour and ingredient quality. Good biltong should look appetising, smell clean and have a texture that suits your preference.

Here is a simple checklist:

  • Check the smell: It should smell savoury, spiced and meaty.
  • Look at the texture: Choose soft, medium or dry depending on what you like.
  • Ask about the cut: Quality biltong usually starts with quality beef cuts.
  • Look for balanced seasoning: The spice should not completely overpower the meat.
  • Buy from a specialist: A dedicated biltong shop or butcher is more likely to understand proper curing, drying and slicing.

If you are new to biltong, try a few styles before deciding what you prefer. Some customers love soft fatty biltong, while others prefer lean dry biltong with a stronger chew.

You can explore our biltong range online or visit Dry Age Biltong in Woodvale, Perth, to choose your preferred flavour, cut and texture.

Conclusion

The difference between good and bad biltong comes down to meat quality, seasoning, drying, storage and texture. Good biltong should be clean, savoury, balanced and enjoyable to eat. Bad biltong often tastes stale, smells off, feels unpleasant or relies too heavily on spice.

When you choose biltong from a specialist who understands the process, you get a better flavour, better texture and a more authentic South African-style snack.